top of page

You Are SO Beautiful!

Avigail Gimpel
Nov 5
12 min read

Parshat Chayei Sarah — When a Gift Becomes an Identity


Dedicated to the memory of our fallen heroes: Ephraim, son of Liat and Shmuel; Yosef Malachi, son of Dina and David; Eliyahu Moshe Shlomo, son of Sarah and Shimon; Yosef Chaim, son of Rachel and Eliyahu; Netanel, son of Revital and Elad; Yakir, son of Chaya and Yehoshua; Ran, son of Sarah and Kenny; Harel, son of Yonat and Shlomo; and Tomer, son of Adina and Isaac.

May their memories be a blessing, may their souls be elevated, and may their families find strength and comfort. May we be worthy of the extraordinary sacrifices made for the people and land of Israel.


A very warm welcome home to Oscar and Evelyn Kranz, who have just made Aliyah from Great Neck! We are so thrilled that you are finally here to stay! May this new chapter bring you endless blessings, joy, and a wonderful sense of belonging. Welcome home!


Can We Please Talk About Beauty?


I have a confession. Every time the Torah tells me that a woman was beautiful, my skin crawls a little. Even admitting that I noticed feels embarrassing. Seriously, is this what I'm choosing to investigate in the Torah?

In Parshat Chayei Sarah, Rashi tells us that Sarah was as beautiful at twenty as she was at seven. Then Rivka arrives, and the Torah tells us she was exceptionally beautiful.

Oh, great. Here we go. Is this my cue to look away?

Fortunately, there are plenty of explanations to rescue us from this terribly shallow conversation. Sarah was a tzadeket! Rivka had wonderful middot! Her inner beauty made her glow! Remember the three miracles in Sarah's tent? Sheker hachen vehevel hayofi—charm is deceptive and beauty is fleeting! There, we've restored the Torah's dignity. Can we move on?

Except I don't want to move on.

Have you not heard things like, "If you're skinny, I assume you have no problems," or "Beautiful girls always have it together"? Then there are the nastier comments: "She probably got that position because of her looks," or "He's rich enough to get himself a pretty wife."

Apparently, someone's appearance tells us everything about their life, character, and accomplishments. Who knew?

At this point in my life, I have a lot less patience for glossing over uncomfortable truths. I've spent enough years watching the beauty game to know how ridiculous, powerful, and painful it can be. Yet even raising this subject makes me feel a little ashamed.

Get back in line, lady. Be tzanua.

There it is! We haven't even started, and somehow the modesty conversation has already entered the room.

But the Torah describes physical beauty, in women and men. We all know how loaded this subject is. We've judged ourselves, compared ourselves to others, felt insecure, been admired, dismissed, envied, or misunderstood because of appearance.

Why does God create beauty? Why do we want it? What does it give us, and why can it cause so much pain?

For once, I want to take the Torah at its word.

Sarah was beautiful. Rivka was beautiful.

Let's talk about it.


Apparently, God Likes Beautiful Things


I went looking for some clear guidance. Surely Chazal would help me sort this out.

My first discovery was almost embarrassingly straightforward: God seems to like beautiful things.

In Gan Eden, God creates trees that are נחמד למראה וטוב למאכל—pleasing to the eye and good for food (Bereishit 2:9). The trees provide nourishment, but God also makes them beautiful. A functional tree wasn't enough. He wanted one worth looking at.

Chazal teach that three things broaden a person's perspective: a beautiful home, a beautiful spouse, and beautiful possessions (Berakhot 57b). Beauty contributes something beyond usefulness. It can bring pleasure and a sense of spaciousness to our lives.

We even have a blessing associated with encountering extraordinary beauty: ברוך שככה לו בעולמו—blessed is He who has such things in His world (Berakhot 58b).

In Avodah Zarah 20a, Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel sees an exceptionally beautiful woman and exclaims, מה רבו מעשיך ה׳!—how abundant are Your works, God!

He sees beauty and praises the Creator. He doesn't ask whether she is righteous, intelligent, or kind. Her physical beauty itself inspires praise.

Could it be that a beautiful person reflects something of God's creative abundance, just as a magnificent garden reflects something of the gardener who planted it? A beautiful garden doesn't have to justify its existence by producing better fruit. Its beauty is already contributing something to the world.

Then I encountered Rabbi Yochanan.

The Gemara in Bava Metzia 84a tells us that Rabbi Yochanan was extraordinarily handsome. He would sit near the place where women emerged from the mikvah, hoping that seeing him would lead them to have children as beautiful and learned in Torah as he was.

Are you as uncomfortable as I am?

Rabbi Yochanan knew he was beautiful. He appreciated his appearance and considered beauty something desirable enough to wish upon future generations.

He didn't claim that beautiful children would necessarily be better people. He wished for children who were beautiful and learned in Torah. Two wonderful gifts.

I was beginning to relax.

Perhaps beauty really is something God deliberately placed in His world for us to enjoy. Perhaps we can appreciate our appearance, admire beauty in others, and even thank God for it.

Could good looks actually be that simple?

Nah.


So Why Did the Shepherd Cut His Hair?


Just when I was beginning to feel comfortable, along comes Shimon HaTzaddik with a story that threatens to ruin everything.

In Nedarim 9b, he describes a young shepherd with beautiful eyes and magnificent curls. One day, the shepherd catches sight of his reflection in the water and is overwhelmed by his own beauty.

He addresses his יצר הרע:

Why are you becoming arrogant in a world that doesn't belong to you?

He then takes a Nazirite vow, knowing that he will eventually have to shave off his beautiful hair. When Shimon HaTzaddik hears his story, he kisses him on the head and praises him.

Hold on. What exactly am I supposed to learn from this?

We have just established that beauty is a gift from God, something to enjoy, something that can even inspire a blessing. Now a young man appreciates his own beauty, and the heroic response is to get rid of it?

I can already hear the מוסר שמועס: You think you're pretty? Better do something about that. Stop looking in the mirror. Make yourself less attractive. Be humble.

That interpretation frightens me far more than the shepherd's reflection.

Imagine teaching a young girl that enjoying her appearance is a sign of arrogance, or that the safest way to remain righteous is to make herself less beautiful. We could turn a gift into a source of shame and call it holiness.

But perhaps I've misunderstood what frightened the shepherd.

He never says that his beauty is bad. He asks why he is becoming arrogant over something that doesn't belong to him. His reflection has begun to change the way he sees himself.

He is in danger of confusing a gift he received with a personal achievement, allowing that gift to become the foundation of his identity.

His response is extreme, and Shimon HaTzaddik praises his extraordinary determination. But does that mean the rest of us should imitate the haircut?

Rabbi Yochanan certainly didn't seem embarrassed by his own good looks.

So perhaps the lesson is that we can appreciate our gifts, provided we remember that they come from God.

Fine. That sounds like a respectable מוסר message.

Except that it doesn't come close to explaining the emotional mess surrounding beauty.


When a Gift Becomes Currency


Beauty has a peculiar quality. It belongs to the person who possesses it, but much of its social value is determined by everyone else.

Every society has its currencies. Wealth opens doors. Intelligence earns recognition. Family background creates connections. Talent attracts admiration. Depending on the time and place, beauty can be worth an extraordinary amount.

On ט״ו באב, the Gemara describes young women dancing in the vineyards, hoping to find husbands. The beautiful women encourage prospective husbands to consider beauty, while women from distinguished families emphasize their lineage (Ta'anit 31a).

They know what they bring to the table, and they aren't embarrassed to say so.

I found that refreshing. Beauty is an advantage. So is wealth, intelligence, or coming from a respected family. These gifts can create genuine opportunities.

But currency is a funny thing. Its value depends on the marketplace.

What makes someone desirable in one culture may barely register in another. The same body, talent, or family background can carry entirely different social value depending on who is looking.

And what happens when the marketplace becomes the mirror through which we see ourselves?

The beautiful girl becomes the pretty one. The gifted child becomes the genius. The wealthy man becomes the rich guy.

Suddenly, a characteristic that was supposed to be part of our lives becomes the way we measure our value.

Elizabeth Gilbert explores a similar problem in her TED talk Your Elusive Creative Genius. She challenges the notion that a creative person is a genius, suggesting instead that genius is something a person receives or works with. The distinction allows us to appreciate extraordinary talent without making our entire identity depend on it.

Cameron Russell, in Looks Aren't Everything. Believe Me, I'm a Model, describes the real advantages of physical attractiveness alongside the insecurity and assumptions that accompany it.

One addresses the danger of identifying ourselves with our gifts. The other reveals what happens when the world identifies us with them.

I began thinking about all the people I have known who have struggled with both sides of this equation.

The shame of wanting to be noticed. The shame of being noticed. The shame of not being noticed.

The person who spends hours trying to become more attractive and the person who deliberately makes herself less attractive. The person who enjoys a compliment and immediately feels guilty. The person who dismisses every compliment because accepting it would feel vain, shameful.

The comparisons, the jealousy, the insecurity, the exhausting calculations about where we stand.

Are we supposed to stop caring about beauty? Enjoy it? Hide it? Use it? Ignore it?

I was hoping for a clean answer, and the more I looked, the more complicated it became.


When the Mirror Becomes a Battlefield


Then I thought about Shaul and David.

Shaul is introduced as an exceptionally handsome young man, taller than everyone around him (I Shmuel 9:2). When he is first chosen as king, he seems almost reluctant to accept the attention. But as his story unfolds, his relationship with public approval becomes increasingly destructive. He admits to Shmuel that he feared the people (I Shmuel 15:24). Even after being confronted with his failures, he asks Shmuel to honor him publicly before the elders.

Then David arrives.

After David's military successes, the women sing that Shaul has slain his thousands and David his tens of thousands. Shaul becomes furious. From that point onward, David's success increasingly threatens him. His insecurity grows into jealousy, suspicion, and eventually attempts to kill David.

Was Shaul's beauty responsible? The text certainly doesn't say that. His struggle concerns kingship, public standing, and the fear of losing his position.

But the pattern is painfully familiar.

When our identity becomes dependent on something the world admires, someone else's success can feel like an attack on our very existence.

But here's the irony.

When Shmuel is sent to anoint the next king, God explicitly warns him against judging by appearance or height: כי האדם יראה לעינים וה׳ יראה ללבב—man sees what is visible to the eyes, but God sees the heart (I Shmuel 16:7).

Finally, David appears, and the Torah describes him as handsome, with beautiful eyes and a pleasing appearance.

Really?

We have just been warned against judging by appearance, and now we're being told how good-looking David is?

Perhaps the Torah is making a distinction I have been struggling to make.

Beauty can be real and worth noticing without becoming the measure of a person's worth.

God sees David's heart. That doesn't require us to pretend David isn't handsome.


What If the Problem Is the Person Looking?


But even that distinction leaves me frustrated.

Suppose I've managed to appreciate my appearance without making it my identity. Suppose I know that my beauty is a gift and that my worth doesn't depend on it. That would be an objectively impressive success.

What happens when everyone else insists on making it my identity anyway?

Sarah knows something about that.

As Avraham approaches Egypt, he tells her, הנה נא ידעתי כי אשה יפת מראה את—I know that you are a beautiful woman (Bereishit 12:11).

Rashi explains that Avraham had known about Sarah's beauty for years. What changed was that they were entering a place where her beauty could put them in danger.

Sarah hadn't changed. The environment had.

Her beauty became something powerful men wanted to possess, and Pharaoh took her into his household.

Sarah's appearance was a gift. Pharaoh's response was his responsibility.

This is an entirely different problem from the shepherd admiring his reflection.

The shepherd was struggling with his own pride. Pharaoh was responding to someone else's beauty with entitlement.

We can work on our humility, our gratitude, and our self-perception. But we cannot control another person's jealousy, assumptions, desire, or resentment.

Even in religious communities, where צניעות is an important value, the message can sometimes become that a beautiful woman's body is a problem because of what it might cause other people to think.

There is a difference between teaching modesty and making someone feel ashamed of a gift God gave them.

I kept hoping to find a source that would tell the beautiful person exactly how to behave so that everyone could finally be comfortable.

But perhaps that expectation is itself part of the problem.


Why Mention Beauty When It Changes Nothing?


Then I began noticing something else.

The Torah sometimes tells us that someone is beautiful even when that beauty seems to contribute remarkably little to the story.

Take Avigail.

In I Shmuel 25:3, she is introduced as טובת שכל ויפת תאר—intelligent and beautiful.

When David is preparing to attack Naval's household, Avigail intervenes with extraordinary courage, judgment, and diplomacy. She brings provisions, approaches David, and persuades him to reconsider.

Her intelligence changes the course of events.

Her beauty? The narrative doesn't clearly tell us what role it plays.

Why mention it?

Or consider Rivka.

והנערה טבת מראה מאד—the young woman was exceptionally beautiful (Bereishit 24:16).

But Eliezer's test concerns her generosity. She offers him water and then draws water for his camels. Her family negotiates the marriage, and Rivka makes the extraordinary decision to leave home.

Her beauty doesn't determine Eliezer's test or her decision.

David is handsome, but God chooses him for reasons that go beyond appearance. Avigail is beautiful, but her wisdom drives her story. Rivka is exceptionally beautiful, but her choices reveal who she is.

I had been searching for the purpose of their beauty, as though every gift must perform some specific function to justify its presence.

What if that is the wrong question?

A beautiful garden doesn't have to produce better fruit to justify being beautiful. We can admire its beauty, thank God for it, and continue enjoying the garden.

Perhaps the Torah can tell us that someone is beautiful simply because that is one of the gifts God gave them.

It is part of their story without needing to become the story.

And suddenly, I found myself returning to the very first Rashi that had made me so uncomfortable.


Beautiful at Seven



Rashi describes Sarah at twenty as being as beautiful as she was at seven.

I know Rashi is speaking about her physical appearance, but I can't stop thinking about that seven-year-old girl.

A child who can enjoy being beautiful without having to calculate what her beauty is worth. Without needing to be the prettiest girl in the room, feeling guilty for being noticed, or wondering what everyone else's appearance says about her own.

Of course, children can compare themselves and struggle with appearance too. But there is something about the image of a seven-year-old that suggests the possibility of beauty before it becomes an elaborate social identity.

Can we carry that freedom into adulthood?

Perhaps Sarah offers us a model of a woman whose beauty was real, admired, and sometimes dangerous, yet never became the center of her life.

Rivka offers another possibility. She is exceptionally beautiful, and then she gets on with the business of being Rivka.

Avigail uses her intelligence and courage. David is chosen for what God sees in his heart. Rabbi Yochanan seems perfectly comfortable appreciating his own attractiveness and even trying to use it for a purpose he considers valuable.

The shepherd reminds us how easily we can become infatuated with our gifts. Shaul shows us the danger of building our identity around public admiration. Pharaoh demonstrates what happens when someone else's beauty becomes something we believe we are entitled to possess.

We began this investigation hoping to find one clear instruction about beauty. Something we could finally hold on to after years of discomfort, comparison, guilt, and confusion.

Instead, we found people relating to beauty in dramatically different ways.

We found Chazal celebrating it, a shepherd frightened by it, a king consumed by comparison, and a woman endangered by someone else's desire.

We found beauty contributing to the world, opening doors, creating opportunities, and sometimes causing enormous pain.

We wanted someone to tell us exactly how we were supposed to feel about it.

But perhaps the Torah is offering something more useful than a prescribed feeling.

Beauty is a gift. It is real, it is valuable, and it is ours to appreciate. We didn't create it, we cannot guarantee that we will keep it, and it was never meant to carry the weight of our entire identity.

We can enjoy it without worshipping it. We can recognize it without apologizing for it. We can admire it in others without turning their beauty into a judgment about ourselves or them.

Chazal even gave us a blessing for encountering extraordinary beauty: ברוך שככה לו בעולמו.

Blessed is God who has such things in His world.

What a relief it would be to look at beauty, including our own, and respond with gratitude rather than a running calculation of what it means about us.

We began this investigation embarrassed that we even wanted to talk about physical beauty. We kept hoping the sources would tell us what we were supposed to do with it.

Perhaps we've been asking beauty to answer a question it was never meant to answer: Who are we?

We are people with lives to live, choices to make, people to love, and a collection of gifts we didn't create.

Beauty may be one of them.

And perhaps the greatest freedom is to appreciate that gift with all the delight of a seven-year-old, then get on with the extraordinary business of being ourselves.

 
 
 

3 Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Guest
Nov 08
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

See the noam elimelech on the parashah. He says similar to you about Sara's beauty

Like

Sara
Nov 06
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

Wow! Just wow

Like

rachael
Nov 05
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

as usual, I loved this dvar Torah. you took what is often a slippery slope and helped me to look at it with Torah infused vision. thank you and Shabbat Shalom

Like
bottom of page