Are the Jews to Blame for Antisemitism?
Parshat Toldot: Two Brothers, One Birthright, and the Hatred That Refuses to Die
Dedicated to the precious souls of our fallen soldiers, whose beautiful lives were stolen by the evils of this relentless hatred, and whose courage, sacrifice, and unfinished dreams remind us of the unbearable human cost of antisemitism.
L'ilui Nishmat: Ephraim ben Liat v'Shmuel • Yosef Malachi ben Dina v'David • Eliyahu Moshe Shlomo ben Sarah v'Shimon • Yosef Chaim ben Rachel v'Eliyahu • Netanel ben Revital v'Elad • Yakir ben Chaya v'Yehoshua • Ron ben Sarah v'Kenny • Harel ben Yonat v'Shlomo • Tomer ben Adina v'Isaac
The Question We're Not Supposed to Ask

Antisemitism is so insidious that even attempting to investigate its origins can become an exercise in confusion.
When I began researching this essay, I asked ChatGPT to help me find Torah sources that might explain the extraordinary persistence of antisemitism. One of its first responses was to suggest setting aside the question of whether Jewish behavior might be contributing to the hatred.
I was stunned. Why was that even a question? I hadn't suggested it. I wasn't asking whether the Jews had done something to deserve the hatred directed at them. I was asking why the hatred exists.
Yet throughout our conversation, the qualifications kept appearing. We must be careful about calling someone an antisemite. We cannot know what is in another person's heart. Even in a conversation devoted to understanding antisemitism, there was a persistent impulse to qualify, redirect, and soften the discussion. I found this deeply disturbing, but also revealing.
Consider two recent examples. In February 2026, Tucker Carlson questioned whether Israeli Jews were truly descended from the ancient Jewish people and proposed genetic testing to establish who belonged to Abraham's family. In November, Joe Rogan repeated claims that genetic testing was restricted in Israel because many Israeli Jews were not actually Semites, suggesting that Palestinians were the real Semites and may have been the original Jews.
Think about the extraordinary nature of these arguments. We do not ordinarily demand that British people submit DNA tests to establish that they are authentically British. We do not tell an entire nation that its historical identity is fraudulent and that its enemies are the real inheritors of its identity. Yet when it comes to Jews, even the question of whether we are who we say we are seems perpetually open for debate.
What is so threatening about the continued existence of the Jewish people that even our identity must be challenged?
The Torah offers us a way to investigate this question, beginning with a conflict that predates modern politics, Christianity, Islam, and the establishment of the State of Israel.
It begins in Rivka's womb.
Two Children, One Root
After twenty years of waiting for a child, Rivka finally becomes pregnant. Instead of the peace she might have expected, she experiences a violent internal struggle: ויתרוצצו הבנים בקרבה — the children struggled within her. Rivka is so disturbed that she cries out, אם כן למה זה אנכי — if this is so, why am I?
I find it difficult to believe that Rivka, the woman who demonstrated extraordinary strength and determination when she watered Eliezer's camels, was simply overwhelmed by pregnancy discomfort. Something about this pregnancy seemed profoundly wrong. She may have believed she was carrying one child whose inner world was being torn apart by opposing forces.
Rivka turns to Hashem and receives an astonishing answer: שני גוים בבטנך — there are two nations within you. She is carrying two children with different spiritual natures and missions. Both are hers, both come from the same root, and neither has yet chosen evil. Understanding that the struggle has a purpose may have brought her tremendous relief.
The Shem MiShmuel offers a deep framework for understanding these brothers. He compares Yaakov and Esav to the two trees in Gan Eden: the Tree of Life and the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil.
We tend to think of the Tree of Knowledge as the forbidden tree, the source of humanity's downfall. But why did Hashem create it?
The Shem MiShmuel explains that the two trees represent essential forms of spiritual service. The Tree of Life represents עשה טוב — do good — cultivating goodness and elevating the physical world toward holiness. The Tree of Knowledge represents סור מרע — turn away from evil — recognizing destructive impulses, mastering them, and establishing boundaries that protect goodness. Both trees emerged from one root, both had a positive purpose, and both were necessary.
This corresponds to Adam's first assignment in Gan Eden: לעבדה ולשמרה — to cultivate the garden and guard it.
A garden cannot flourish without both. We can plant beautiful flowers, but without protection they will not survive. We can build the strongest fences, but without cultivation, what have we accomplished? Boundaries create the conditions in which life can flourish, and goodness gives those boundaries its purpose.
According to the Shem MiShmuel, Yaakov and Esav were intended to embody these complementary responsibilities. Yaakov would cultivate holiness, while Esav would develop the strength to confront evil. Together, they could have created a world in which spiritual life was both protected and elevated.
But Esav's assignment was particularly demanding. Before he could protect anyone else, he would have to learn to govern himself.
The Birthright: From Responsibility to Resentment
Esav was born with powerful inclinations, but the Shem MiShmuel explains that this did not mean he was destined for wickedness. His task was to confront those inclinations and develop extraordinary spiritual strength. He might even have reached a level greater than Yaakov.
Every meaningful journey begins with the willingness to look inward. Before I can establish healthy boundaries with the world, I must recognize the boundaries I need within myself. Before I can exercise authority responsibly, I must accept that I am not the ultimate authority.
Esav was meant to become a king, but a king who cannot govern himself is not a protector. He is a danger.
Esav returns from the field exhausted and hungry. Yaakov is preparing food, and Esav agrees to sell his birthright in exchange for a meal. The Torah describes what follows in five rapid actions: ויאכל וישת ויקם וילך ויבז עשו את הבכורה. He ate, drank, got up, left, and despised the birthright.
Esav is living entirely within the experience of the moment. He is hungry, uncomfortable, and desperate for relief. The birthright, however, represents something fundamentally different: a place within a structure of inheritance, obligation, and responsibility.
Think about the oldest child in a family. The eldest often becomes a bridge between parents and younger siblings, helping carry the values and responsibilities of the household forward. It is a demanding position that requires maturity and the willingness to put something larger than one's immediate desires first. The birthright is not simply a prize. It is a responsibility.
Esav wants the freedom to determine what matters according to his immediate needs. He sells the birthright and then devalues it. Yet when Yaakov later receives Yitzchak's blessing, Esav becomes furious and accuses his brother: את בכורתי לקח — he took my birthright.
But Esav sold it. He made an agreement, received what he wanted, and walked away. Now, confronted with the consequences, he tells a different story. His brother has wronged him.
He is the victim.
Here we begin to understand how rejection becomes resentment. Esav sees his own disappointment but not his responsibility. He feels his own pain but cannot recognize the story from his brother's perspective. He cannot tolerate the consequences of his choices, so he turns against the person who now carries the responsibility he abandoned.
The brother who could have been his greatest partner becomes his enemy.
David HaMelech: The King Esav Could Have Become
There is a fascinating connection between Esav and David HaMelech. Both are described as אדמוני — ruddy — and Bereishit Rabbah 63:8 draws an explicit comparison between them. The Midrash explains that Esav exercises violence according to his own judgment, while David submits the power of life and death to the authority of the Sanhedrin.
Both possess tremendous power and the capacity for violence. The difference is whether that power submits to a moral authority beyond the self.
David's story becomes even more revealing when Natan HaNavi confronts him about Batsheva and Uriah. David has crossed a terrible moral boundary and caused devastating harm. Yet when Natan forces him to face his actions, David responds: חטאתי לה׳ — I have sinned against Hashem.
David does not blame Batsheva for his choices, nor does he turn against Natan for making him uncomfortable. He acknowledges his wrongdoing and accepts responsibility. His admission does not erase the consequences, but it allows him to begin the process of repentance.
This is something I see in relationships. Imagine a husband who has been unfaithful to his wife. When she discovers the betrayal, she is devastated. He can follow David's example: I betrayed my marriage. I caused my wife tremendous pain. I need to understand how I crossed that boundary and begin the difficult work of repair.
Or he can follow Esav's example: I was lonely. She wasn't giving me what I needed. Now she's making me feel terrible about myself, and I can't stand how she treats me.
Notice what has happened. His wife's pain, caused by his betrayal, has become the offense. Her insistence on accountability becomes an attack against him. He has made himself the victim of the very suffering he caused.
What is missing is not only self-control, but empathy: the ability to recognize that another person's experiences, needs, and feelings matter just as much as our own. Without empathy, the world begins and ends with our discomfort. Other people exist to satisfy our needs, and when they fail to do so, they become responsible for our suffering.
David demonstrates another possibility. He can hear the truth about himself, acknowledge the suffering he has caused, and accept that the rules do not revolve around his desires.
This is the beginning of סור מרע — turning away from evil. Our feelings, however real, do not determine what is right.
Rivka's Impossible Decision
Rivka now faces a heartbreaking reality. The two sons who were meant to fulfill complementary missions are no longer moving toward a shared purpose. Esav has rejected the discipline required for his role, and Yaakov must assume both responsibilities.
The Shem MiShmuel explains that Yaakov must now undertake the work of the Tree of Knowledge alongside the work of the Tree of Life. He must learn not only how to cultivate holiness, but how to confront the forces that threaten it.
Rivka understands this world. She grew up in the household of Betuel and Lavan, surrounded by manipulation and deception. Yaakov, by contrast, is described as an איש תם יושב אהלים — a sincere, straightforward man who dwelled in tents. His strengths have developed in a very different environment.
When Rivka directs Yaakov to receive Yitzchak's blessing, she introduces him to a world requiring courage, strategy, and uncomfortable choices. Yaakov hesitates, fearing that his father will discover the deception and curse him. Rivka responds, עלי קללתך בני — let your curse be upon me, my son.
After Esav threatens Yaakov's life, Rivka sends him away to Lavan. Imagine what this costs her as a mother. She is sending her beloved son into the very environment from which she herself escaped. She knows the kind of people he will encounter and cannot protect him from the pain ahead. She cannot know when she will see him again. The Torah never records their reunion.
The Shem MiShmuel sees Yaakov's journey to Lavan as a spiritual education. Yaakov must acquire the strength, discernment, and capacity for turning away from evil that Esav failed to develop. Through his struggles, he prepares a path for his descendants.
Rivka cannot give Yaakov those skills by keeping him safe. The son who was meant to cultivate the garden must now learn how to guard it as well.
The Hatred That Refuses to Die
When Yaakov finally prepares to meet Esav again, he is no longer the sheltered man who fled his parents' home. His years with Lavan have taught him to recognize manipulation, protect his family, negotiate, and stand his ground.
Facing Esav, Yaakov prepares through three approaches, which Rashi identifies as gifts, prayer, and readiness for war. He understands that he must prepare for danger while continuing to seek reconciliation. He has developed the capacities of both doing good and turning away from evil.
The brothers embrace, but they do not continue together. Esav invites Yaakov to Seir, and Yaakov replies, ואני אתנהלה לאטי — I will proceed slowly. He explains that the children and animals cannot be pushed beyond their capacity. His responsibility is to protect the lives entrusted to him.
Rashi makes an extraordinary observation. Yaakov promises that he will eventually come to Seir, but the Torah never records that visit. Rashi explains that the promise will be fulfilled in the days of Mashiach, citing Ovadiah:
ועלו מושיעים בהר ציון לשפט את הר עשו והיתה לה׳ המלוכה — Deliverers will ascend Mount Zion to judge the mountain of Esav, and the kingship will belong to Hashem.
The reunion is real, but the story is not finished.
Hashem tells Moshe to declare to Pharaoh, בני בכורי ישראל — Israel is My firstborn son (Shemot 4:22). Yaakov was not born first, yet he became the bearer of the birthright and received the blessing that would carry Avraham's covenant forward. The Jewish people inherited a demanding relationship with Hashem, expressed through Torah, mitzvot, and the responsibility to bring holiness into the world.
This brings us back to the questions with which we began. Why does antisemitism persist across centuries, cultures, and political circumstances? Why do its accusations change so dramatically while the hatred remains recognizable?
The conflict between Yaakov and Esav offers a spiritual explanation. Esav's resentment develops when he refuses his own mission, rejects responsibility for his decisions, and directs his anger toward the brother who carries the role he abandoned.
The grievances can change because the resentment precedes them. What Esav cannot tolerate is the continued existence of a moral structure he wants to reject, represented by a brother who continues to live within it.
This is what makes contemporary attacks on Jewish identity so revealing. When Tucker Carlson questions Jewish ancestry or Joe Rogan repeats claims that the Jews are not really the Jews, the argument challenges the legitimacy of Jewish identity itself.
It is a modern echo of את בכורתי לקח — he took my birthright.
The Jewish people have carried their covenant through exile, persecution, dispersion, and return. Yet the accusation persists that the identity, history, or inheritance they claim is somehow not theirs.
The story has changed. The resentment has not.
Ovadiah: The Reckoning Still to Come
There is one final question that the Torah's account leaves unresolved. If Yaakov has learned to carry both responsibilities, what becomes of Esav? Can the brother who abandoned his spiritual mission ever return to it?
The prophet Ovadiah speaks directly to Edom, the nation descended from Esav. He condemns its violence against Yaakov and its participation in the suffering of Jerusalem. The prophecy declares: מחמס אחיך יעקב תכסך בושה — because of the violence against your brother Yaakov, shame will cover you.
Then comes the principle of accountability: כאשר עשית יעשה לך, גמלך ישוב בראשך — as you have done, so shall it be done to you; your deeds will return upon your own head.
This is the reckoning Esav has avoided since the sale of the birthright. He cannot continue indefinitely to blame his brother while refusing to confront the consequences of his own actions.
But the prophecy raises a difficult question. Does this reckoning offer Esav an opportunity to reclaim his original mission, or does it describe the destruction of the path he chose? Ovadiah speaks of judgment, and its language is severe. It does not explicitly promise Esav's repentance.
Still, the final words are extraordinary: והיתה לה׳ המלוכה — the kingship will belong to Hashem.
The original temptation in Gan Eden was the promise that humanity could become its own ultimate authority, deciding good and evil according to its desires. Esav's failure followed that same path. He wanted the freedom to define his own obligations and then rejected the consequences when reality refused to accommodate him.
The prophetic vision ends with the restoration of divine authority. Human power, ambition, and desire can no longer claim to stand above the moral order established by Hashem.
Whether Esav himself can return to his original mission remains an open question. But the two trees were created from one root, and both were necessary. The final redemption must bring the work of cultivating goodness and guarding it into harmony.
Perhaps that is the deepest hope contained in Yaakov's unfinished promise to his brother: עד אשר אבא אל אדני שעירה — until I come to my lord at Seir.
The journey is not yet complete.
.webp)



Excellent thanks
Thanks for sharing, very powerful!