Who Got Faith Right?
Three paths to God, the strength of family, and the gift of recognizing His presence
Parshat Vayetzei
Dedicated לעילוי נשמת our fallen soldiers: Ephraim ben Liat v’Shmuel, Yosef Malachi ben Dina v’David, Eliyahu Moshe Shlomo ben Sarah v’Shimon, Yosef Chaim ben Rachel v’Eliyahu, Netanel ben Revital v’Elad, Yakir ben Chaya v’Yehoshua, Ron ben Sara v’Kenny, Harel ben Yonat v’Shlomo, and Tomer ben Adina v’Izik, whose courage and sacrifice in defense of Am Yisrael and Eretz Yisrael will forever be part of our nation's story.
Sometimes We Only See It Looking Back
I'm in America right now, missing home terribly, but also enjoying precious time with family I

love so much. I'm incredibly grateful for this opportunity to be together, and there's something about visiting family when we live so far apart that makes me appreciate these relationships even more.
Spending time with my younger siblings has gotten me thinking about a particularly difficult time in our lives. Back then, I felt like I had to be strong for them, and because they needed me, I was determined to be there for them. But looking back, I realize something I didn't understand at the time. I thought I was the one holding them up, but in so many ways, they were holding me up. Being needed, loving them, and having that connection gave me the strength to keep going.
It's funny how sometimes we only recognize what's been carrying us when we look back.
I think our relationship with God can be like that too. We believe He's always there, that there's a plan, but actually getting to see His fingerprints in our lives is an extraordinary gift. Sometimes we recognize them right away, sometimes years later, and sometimes we never get that clarity.

So what do we do in the meantime? How do we stay connected to God through all the ups and downs of life, when we feel His presence and when we don't?
I think Parshat Vayetzei gives us a fascinating answer. As the first Jewish family is taking shape, we meet three remarkable people, Yaakov, Leah, and Rachel, who each find a different way to build and maintain their relationship with God.
And it raises an interesting question: Which one of them actually got faith right?
Three People, Three Very Different Journeys
At first glance, Yaakov seems to have an enormous advantage because God speaks directly to him, promising to protect him, accompany him wherever he goes, and eventually bring him home. Leah and Rachel receive no such direct reassurance in these narratives, yet they develop equally powerful relationships with God.
Yaakov responds to his extraordinary encounters by making vows, erecting monuments, and creating commitments. Leah seems to turn inward, recognizing her deepest feelings and continually giving voice to what she is experiencing. Rachel, meanwhile, seems to turn outward, taking initiative, making decisions, and trying to influence the circumstances of her life.
So which approach is the right one? Is faith about holding on to moments of divine connection, expressing our innermost feelings through prayer, or getting up and doing something?
Perhaps the Torah is suggesting that these three people aren't competing to demonstrate the best form of faith. They're showing us three different ways to maintain a relationship with God through the full experience of being human.
And what better place to teach us this than in the story of the family from which we all come?
Yaakov: Giving Inspiration an Anchor
Yaakov begins his journey running away from home, alone and uncertain of his future. He stops for the night, places a stone beneath his head, and dreams of a ladder stretching between heaven and earth, with angels ascending and descending. God promises to accompany him, protect him, and bring him home.
When Yaakov awakens, he says:
אָכֵן יֵשׁ ה׳ בַּמָּקוֹם הַזֶּה וְאָנֹכִי לֹא יָדָעְתִּי
Surely God is in this place, and I did not know it. (Bereishit 28:16)
I love this pasuk because Yaakov isn't describing God suddenly arriving somewhere. He's realizing that God was there all along, even before he recognized His presence.
That realization gives him extraordinary strength. The Torah tells us, Vayisa Yaakov raglav, Yaakov lifted his feet and continued his journey. Rashi explains that after receiving God's promise, his heart lifted his feet. Although his circumstances haven't changed, his awareness that God is accompanying him transforms the way he continues forward.
But Yaakov does something else that I find fascinating. He takes the stone, raises it as a monument, pours oil upon it, and makes a vow, giving his spiritual experience a tangible expression that can endure beyond the moment.
A little later, Yaakov meets Rachel at the well, single-handedly rolls away the heavy stone covering it, and falls in love. He commits to seven years of work to marry her, and the Torah tells us that those years feel like only a few days because of his love.
Later, in Parshat Vayishlach, Yaakov wrestles through the night with a mysterious being and refuses to let go without receiving a blessing. He emerges with a new name, Yisrael, and a limp that will accompany him afterward.
These encounters are certainly not identical, but there is an interesting thread connecting them. A spiritual awakening becomes a monument and a vow, love becomes years of committed labor, and a struggle leaves Yaakov with a blessing, a new name, and a physical reminder of the experience.
Yaakov repeatedly takes powerful experiences and gives them an enduring place in his life.
I think we can all relate to this. We've had moments of inspiration when we feel particularly close to God, understand something with unusual clarity, or become determined to make a change. But those feelings don't last forever, and Yaakov seems to understand the importance of creating something that will sustain the connection after the inspiration fades.
Think about how much of Jewish life is built around tangible reminders and recurring commitments. Mezuzot, tefillin, tzitzit, Shabbat, and daily prayers give us opportunities to return to our relationship with God even on days when we don't feel especially inspired.
What's especially meaningful is that Yaakov's direct encounter with God doesn't spare him from hardship. He will be deceived by Lavan, endure years of exhausting labor, experience terrible family struggles, and eventually describe his life as me'at vera'im, few and difficult (Bereishit 47:9).
His pathway teaches us that divine reassurance doesn't guarantee an easy life, but that moments of connection can become lasting commitments that help sustain us through the difficult ones.
Leah: Bringing Our Real Selves Into the Relationship
Leah's spiritual journey is strikingly different because, unlike Yaakov, she doesn't receive a direct promise from God.
According to the Gemara in Bava Batra 123a, Leah grows up fearing that she is destined to marry Esav. She hears about his character, becomes deeply distressed, and cries and prays. Chazal connect her soft eyes to those tears.
What fascinates me about Leah is her willingness to look inward, recognize what she is afraid of and what she longs for, and bring those feelings into her relationship with God.
When she marries Yaakov, her circumstances remain complicated. Yaakov loves Rachel, and Leah lives with the pain of being the less-loved wife.
The Torah tells us:
וַיַּרְא ה׳ כִּי שְׂנוּאָה לֵאָה
God saw that Leah was unloved. (29:31)
But unlike Yaakov, Leah isn't told directly that God sees her suffering. Instead, we hear her own voice as she names her children, repeatedly expressing her experiences through her understanding of God's involvement in her life.
When Reuven is born, she says, כִּי רָאָה ה׳ בְּעָנְיִי, God has seen my suffering. With Shimon, she says, כִּי שָׁמַע ה׳ כִּי שְׂנוּאָה אָנֹכִי, God has heard that I am unloved. When Levi is born, she hopes that her husband will finally become attached to her, and with Yehuda she declares, הַפַּעַם אוֹדֶה אֶת ה׳, This time I will thank God.
What I find especially meaningful is that Leah's gratitude doesn't erase her longing. Later, when Zevulun is born, she again expresses the hope that Yaakov will honor her, and I don't think that makes her earlier gratitude any less genuine.
We can be incredibly grateful for our children and still be exhausted by parenting. We can love our families and still feel lonely, just as we can recognize tremendous blessings while continuing to feel disappointed about something that hasn't worked out.
Leah doesn't pretend that one emotion cancels out another. She remains connected to what she is actually experiencing and gives those experiences language, whether through prayer, gratitude, longing, or an honest expression of disappointment.
She's certainly not passive, either. She confronts Rachel, negotiates, and makes decisions that shape her family. But what stands out is her willingness to understand her inner world and bring that truth into her relationships, including her relationship with God.
Leah teaches us that we don't have to feel wonderful to be close to God; we can bring our real selves into the relationship.
We can share our gratitude alongside our pain, confusion, disappointment, and fears, without needing to have everything figured out before beginning the conversation. Leah's extraordinary faith is expressed through her willingness to keep that conversation going, even without the direct reassurance that Yaakov received.
Rachel: Faith Through Action
Rachel's journey offers us another approach. Although she is deeply loved by Yaakov, she struggles terribly with infertility, and like Leah, she receives no direct divine promise that everything will work out.
What stands out about Rachel is her determination to act.
According to the Midrash, Rachel gives Leah the identifying signs she had arranged with Yaakov, sparing her sister a terrible humiliation on her wedding night. It's an extraordinary act of generosity, especially considering what Rachel herself stands to lose.
Later, when she struggles with infertility, she confronts Yaakov, offers Bilhah as a way of building a family, and negotiates with Leah for the dudaim. When the family prepares to leave Lavan, she takes her father's teraphim, an action whose motivation is debated by the commentators.
Rachel is actively engaging with her circumstances, looking for possibilities and making choices rather than simply waiting for life to unfold. That doesn't mean every decision she makes is necessarily right, or that she doesn't pray, experience overwhelming emotions, or recognize God's involvement in her life.
But where Leah repeatedly turns inward and gives voice to her experience, Rachel seems especially inclined to look at the world around her and ask, What can I do?
And here's where her story teaches us something important: We can take meaningful action without being able to control the outcome.
Rachel can make choices, pursue possibilities, and act with courage and determination, but she cannot make herself conceive.
Eventually, the Torah tells us:
וַיִּזְכֹּר אֱלֹהִים אֶת רָחֵל וַיִּשְׁמַע אֵלֶיהָ אֱלֹהִים וַיִּפְתַּח אֶת רַחְמָהּ
God remembered Rachel, heard her, and opened her womb. (30:22)
The word remembered is particularly meaningful. God hadn't forgotten Rachel; rather, the Torah uses the language of remembering to describe a moment of divine intervention. Rashi connects this remembrance to Rachel's earlier kindness in giving Leah the identifying signs, suggesting that an act of generosity performed years earlier had not been forgotten.
Of course, Rachel's story doesn't promise that if we act enough, pray enough, or do enough good deeds, God will give us exactly what we want. Life doesn't work that way, and faith doesn't give us control over God's decisions.
What Rachel does teach us is that we are participants in our own lives. We can make choices, help people, build relationships, and take meaningful action even when we have no idea how things will turn out.
Rachel's pathway reminds us that purposeful action can itself be an expression of faith, not because we know what God is going to do, but because we choose to engage with the world He has placed us in.
Three Pathways, One Relationship
Now, I don't want to turn these three extraordinary people into personality types, because Yaakov isn't the only one who makes commitments, Leah isn't the only one who prays, and Rachel isn't the only one who acts.
All three use all three approaches. Yaakov works, struggles, prays, and makes decisions; Leah takes initiative and actively shapes her circumstances; and Rachel expresses her feelings, speaks about God, and prays.
These are different pathways, not exclusive categories, and each is available to every one of us.
Sometimes we need Yaakov's ability to take a moment of clarity and turn it into a commitment. Other times we need Leah's willingness to look inward and honestly express what we're experiencing, or Rachel's determination to get up and do something even when we don't know whether it will work. We might even need all three before lunchtime!
What I find particularly remarkable is that Leah and Rachel build such powerful relationships with God without receiving the direct reassurance Yaakov is given. They have to cultivate that connection through the lives they're living, and their relationships with God are no less meaningful because of it.
Perhaps that's the beauty of these three pathways: each offers a different way of reaching toward the same God, and none is more valuable than the others.
Recognizing God's Fingerprints
There's another beautiful connection running through these stories.
God tells Yaakov, וְהִנֵּה אָנֹכִי עִמָּךְ, Behold, I am with you (28:15).
About Leah, the Torah tells us, וַיַּרְא ה׳, God saw (29:31).
And about Rachel, וַיִּזְכֹּר אֱלֹהִים, God remembered (30:22).
God accompanies Yaakov, sees Leah's suffering, and remembers Rachel, but there's an important difference between what the Torah tells us and what the people living these stories actually know.
Yaakov receives direct reassurance, while Leah and Rachel don't, and even Yaakov goes on to experience years of uncertainty and hardship.
As readers, we have the privilege of seeing the larger picture, recognizing God's involvement across years and generations. But when we're living our own stories, we rarely have that perspective because we can only see the chapter we're currently experiencing.
Sometimes, years later, we look back and recognize that a relationship we thought we were sustaining was actually sustaining us, or that a responsibility we believed was weighing us down was also giving us purpose.
And sometimes we are fortunate enough to recognize God's fingerprints in those discoveries.
But we may also believe deeply that God has a plan without ever understanding why a particular experience unfolded as it did. Faith doesn't require us to pretend that suffering isn't painful or that every difficult experience will eventually make sense.
It invites us to continue building a relationship even when we cannot see the whole picture, and Yaakov, Leah, and Rachel each offer us a way to do that.
The Family We Come From
As I sit here in America, grateful for every moment with my family while missing my family and home in Israel, I keep coming back to the extraordinary significance of this parsha.
We are watching the first Jewish family take shape, and it's a family filled with love, jealousy, heartbreak, disappointment, generosity, courage, and complicated relationships. Somehow, through all of these very human experiences, the foundations of Am Yisrael are being laid.
I find that incredibly comforting because our ancestors didn't hand us a model of faith that only works when life is going well. They showed us how to maintain a relationship with God through the full range of human experience.
Yaakov teaches us to anchor moments of connection in commitments that endure. Leah teaches us to look inward, recognize our experiences, and bring our genuine selves into conversation with God. Rachel teaches us to act, make choices, and participate in life even when we cannot control the outcome.
Perhaps that's part of what makes family such an extraordinary gift. We don't just inherit stories, traditions, and memories; we inherit ways of living, loving, and finding strength.
This visit has reminded me how grateful I am for the family I come from and the relationships that have shaped me, including those whose importance I didn't fully appreciate while I was living through them.
Perhaps that's why Yaakov's words speak to me so powerfully this week:
אָכֵן יֵשׁ ה׳ בַּמָּקוֹם הַזֶּה וְאָנֹכִי לֹא יָדָעְתִּי
Surely God is in this place, and I did not know it.
God was there before Yaakov recognized Him, and the extraordinary gift was being able to see it.
We may not always receive that gift of clarity, but we have inherited three beautiful ways to continue reaching toward God: we can commit like Yaakov, speak like Leah, and act like Rachel, drawing on each pathway as our lives unfold.
The greatest inheritance our first Jewish family gave us is the understanding that faith isn't about feeling God's presence every moment, but about building a relationship with Him that can accompany us through an entire lifetime.
.webp)


Great and fascinating writing. Keep it up😊.